I, personally, rate shows based on the the level of magic I can hear in the music when i close my eyes. I also rate shows on where I go in my head and heart while listening. I care nothing about which songs they play in which set, what order they play them in, which songs go type 2, and which don't etc. Not sure why a lot of people on this site want to keep a phish show in a box. IMHO, phish is at their best when unpredictable. I loved Saturdays show for this reason.