Let's be honest. One does not simply have a bad time at a Phish show. Atlanta '12 was no exception - at least for me. It was a blast.

With that in mind, let's turn to the show. When considering what Phish did on leg 1 and the previous shows in leg 2 this year, it's hard to say that this show will be really memorable for anyone who was not there. Sure there are highlights like there are most nights, but as a show it does not pack the punch of say SF3 or Birmingham or St. Louis (after Atlanta). Not a bad show - but its 3 stars - maybe a little less (but not 2).

Nothing in this show was poorly played, but there are definitely some ups and downs.

Chalkdust> WTU is what you came here for and what people will come back for. And the Antelope was particularly good too.

Would I go to this show again? Of course - but lets not fall all over ourselves about a show that just isn't the caliber of other outings this summer.