Madison Square Garden (MSG)

New York, NY, USA

Top Rated Shows

Highest rated shows at this venue by Phish.net users:

Date Rating
2021-12-30 1 votes 5.0000/5
1995-12-31 1048 votes 4.6527/5
1997-12-30 904 votes 4.6504/5
2023-12-31 1999 votes 4.6368/5
2017-07-25 1644 votes 4.6235/5
2024-12-29 952 votes 4.6176/5
2017-08-06 1178 votes 4.6104/5
1998-12-31 230 votes 4.6087/5
2019-12-30 1406 votes 4.6010/5
1998-12-29 208 votes 4.5962/5

Top Reviews

Highest-rated reviews from shows at this venue:

2013-12-29 by Meatballs 157
When Trey picked up his guitar, I knew immediately this night wouldn’t be about lollipops or unicorns. There was an insidious stare in his eyes as if he would find your childhood pet, dig it up, and eat that son of a bitch for breakfast. Phish was hungry this evening with an insatiable...
2013-12-31 by Walter_Peck 123
I took my 70-year-old dad to this show. He danced his ass off and had the time of his life. Some of you may have seen a skinny old man wandering around the concourse in a white turtleneck. That was him. He was a Baptist minister and theologian for most of his career. He kept asking about Col....
2019-12-30 by phish123 104
Holy shit my mind was completely blown tonight!!! I’ve been to over 250 shows and I was left totally speechless. What just happened???????????? That Tweezer!!!!!! That entire second set!!!!!! The band was so locked in and msg was on fucking fire tonight. I honestly can’t put it into words. WOW....
2017-08-06 by Philbombs77 101
Not a review. Just want to say thank you to the band. These 13 nights, plus the 5 that preceded them, were nothing short of magical. I know a lot of people were talking about parallels with 2016 being kind of average much in the way 1996 didn't quite compare to the year before and after it. And...
2017-07-25 by n00b100 92
Tonight's theme: Jam-Filled. Ooooh, sounds interesting! Set 1: Oh, hmm, Sample opener? Well, that's not really keeping with the cool opener theme they've set so far for the Baker's Dozen, but I guess I'll give it a listen... ...wait, this isn't the normal Sample jam, is it? This is more...
2023-12-31 by phish123 86
What can you really say after witnessing a show like this. Tonight was my 375th show and I was left completely speechless. The energy in the garden was beyond anything I’ve experienced before. Every song played incredibly well with mind blowing jams and bust outs. Thank you Phish for all you’ve...
2018-12-30 by Itch_to_the_nag 85
For most of the 3.0 era phish has left significant time between the nye run and their last official tour date. This can present an issue where 1 show clearly stands out and the others are just that, the other ones.... Tonight’s first set almost felt like an extension third set from last night....
2019-12-30 by mgolia6 75
In a full sprint! (Unedited) Oh man oh boy oh my oh wow. WTF just transpired. Somehow a solid first set seemed like the bait with which we succumbed when all at once the second set was dropped Acme ton-o-bricks style on us like we were Wyle E Coyote thinking we had just lured the road runner to...
2018-12-29 by Itch_to_the_nag 74
All shows will carry a jaded vet’s bias. For me, this was as close to perfect as phish gets. From 46 days —> tweeprise this was a balanced display of creativity and rock. Though some are quick to compare or rate other shows against one another, most should know that this show doesn’t require...
2015-12-30 by n00b100 73
Set 1: Certainly not the worst way to spend just over an hour of your time (a surprisingly short Set 1), aside from the usual "shaking off the cobwebs" occasional bits of rust that come from lengthy layoffs, and a slightly jarring move into BOTT from Simple's ambient zone (always good to see the...

Notable Jam Chart Performances

Individual jam chart entries from this venue:

2024-12-31 My Friend, My Friend (19:59) Set 2 Noteworthy
After a generous helping of the aggressive murk we've perhaps come to expect from recent plays, the jam cools slightly and settles into an atypically groove laden space that pulses with hypnotic energy and drive, eventually sharpening on the edge of Trey's incisive riffing and concluding with a vocal reprise in lieu of the "myfe" ending.
2024-12-29 Ruby Waves (36:37) Set 2 Noteworthy
A colossal, must-hear "Wave" washes over Madison Square Garden. The jam expands exponentially through multiple sections, including contemplative but optimistic melodicism, driving rhythmic play, and harmonically dense electro-funk before finally crash landing back to the "Ruby Waves" theme, concluding the epic journey.
2023-12-31 AC/DC Bag (18:50) Set 2 Noteworthy
In the shadow of a resurrected rhombus, the "March of The Multibeast" opens an improvisational portal fitting of the historic moment. At once dark and strident, sinister and celebratory, what would be an exceptional excursion under any circumstances becomes transformational in context and relentless in effect. Trey's beastly snarl is finally cooled only by the arrival of the mysterious Tela herself.
2023-12-29 Chalk Dust Torture (22:24) Set 2 Noteworthy
A teeth-gnashing multi(sectioned)beast of a jam, this take traverses through various disparate yet cohesively-arranged themes, including hyper-drive psychedelic rock, "Woo's", dense mind-bending dissonance and finally, a stoner/doom metal-esque dirge that grinds down > "Oblivion".
2023-08-05 Prince Caspian (16:25) Set 1 Noteworthy
Truly monstrous first set version marked by tone shifting ferocity and relentless drive that samples from a range of effects, builds through several movements and eventually unleashes an ungodly peak that subsequently deconstructs before segueing to "NICU".
2023-08-04 Mike's Song (23:19) Set 2 Noteworthy
Almost exactly 6 years to the day, "Mike's" gets another monster run as the Set II opener at MSG after 8/2/17's Baker's Dozen stunner. After a spirited, if routine first jam, the second jam forges ahead at 8:45 with a progressively upbeat display of the band's ability to weave a tapestry of interplay as they cycle through the changes. Trey's walkup at 19:20 signals a blowout finale on the horizon which arrives in full a few minutes later, after which the closing chords are repeated, then > "Sand".
2023-08-01 Wolfman's Brother (17:03) Set 1 Noteworthy
Exiting the song proper, Trey wastes no time finding a fat, heavy line. Doing well to push past "The Well" quotes, a truly unique musical conversation ensues, with Mike, in time, dominating much of the discourse. Page is perfect on his piano before jumping to his keys, splashing sound, and moving the jam in a new direction. Worth repeated listens, this is one of Summer 23's actual blockbusters.
2023-08-01 Sample in a Jar (16:36) Set 2 Noteworthy
If Phish plays a residency at MSG, chances are you'll want to hear the version of "Sample" they play there. This second set opener is the longest one played to date. Trey and Mike have some fun interplay which sets the tone for the jam. The band latches onto a real fun groove around 13:30. The end of the jam is awesome and makes you wish they'd keep it going, instead Trey > "Kill Devil Falls."
2023-07-29 Fuego (30:04) Set 2 Noteworthy
Veritable monster of a version that works as an emblematic example of Phish's comfort in MSG. Focused patience marks the affair, as "soundcheck" vibes abound. Eventually the grooves turn spacier and funkier around the 20:00 mark, before building towards a major key rock out. The music then downshifts into heavenly "hose" territory, with Trey looping infectious '99-esque repeated licks and subtly reintegrating the "Fuego" melody for a stunning finale.
2022-12-30 Theme From the Bottom (14:58) Set 1 Noteworthy
Despite some tuning issues in the composed section, the band ultimately delivers the second massive "Theme" of '22. The usual soaring play giving way around 6 min as Trey shifts to a more rhythmic approach and Page adds some crunch on the clav. The jam, gaining momentum, grows darker propelled by Mike's aggressive lines and Fishman's deft cymbal work as Trey's tone becomes grittier. Page moves back to piano and around 11 min the band modulates to a brighter space with Trey continuing to adjust his sound. Play then turns atmospheric under the influence of Page's synths and Mike's bass effects before > to "Reba".
2022-04-23 Simple (1:20) Set 1 Noteworthy
-> Trey pulls out of the "Egg in a Hole Jam" with a deft return to the "Simple" riff for a triumphant conclusion to a mind-blowing segment.
2022-04-23 Egg in a Hole (1:37) Set 1 Noteworthy
"Simple's" incredible exploration gets a slight tweak and lands on the "Egg in a Hole Jam" and then -> back to "Simple".
2022-04-23 Simple (19:08) Set 1 Noteworthy
Initially an upbeat jam that pleasantly bobs along until a switch is flipped around 13:30, launching into a segment of terrifying power and space-age effects -> "Egg in a Hole Jam"
2022-04-23 No Men In No Man's Land (26:40) Set 2 Noteworthy
Arguably "the" jam of this fun and quirky run, the version's quick, plucky tempo features, like an old-school "DWD," fire Trey and a lot of notes - a wonderfully wild array of ideas offset by melodic variation and extended trilling. Straightforward jamming breaks for perhaps the run's most interesting passage, with Trey expertly moving through myriad sounds while swapping deeply textured and patterned play with Mike. The finest in the nation sort of Phish you could listen to all day, improv wherein you can hear the -> into "Caspian" coming from leagues away.
2019-12-30 Tweezer (2:26) Set 2 Noteworthy
Punches out of "Steam" and soars triumphantly, hearkening back to the peak of the set's opening version, before seguing into "Ruby Waves."


Phish.net

Phish.net is a non-commercial project run by Phish fans and for Phish fans under the auspices of the all-volunteer, non-profit Mockingbird Foundation.

This project serves to compile, preserve, and protect encyclopedic information about Phish and their music.

Credits | Terms Of Use | Legal | DMCA

© 1990-2025  The Mockingbird Foundation, Inc.