Page teased The Little Drummer Boy in the first Tweezer. Trey teased Super Bad in Weekapaug. The second setbreak music was comprised of songs referencing past Phish New Year's Eve gags. Before the third set began, a barbershop quartet appeared with a singing telegram for Phish. The telegram said that at the stroke of midnight it would be 40 years for Phish and to make a wish. Trey wished he had a time machine so they could do it all again. A cube descended from overhead and a time machine was revealed near Mike. The quartet activated the time machine and the cube played audio and video from past years of Phish. Dancers from various past new year's gags appeared on stage as well as a wombat (from October 31, 2013). The wombat broke the time machine and Ghost began with dancers and characters (like Father Time from December 31, 1999 and the Famous Mockingbird from December 31, 1992) continuing to appear from the band's past performances. Ghost featured Meatstick lyrics sung from the band as well as by dancers in different languages in a nod to December 31, 2010. The first Bohemian Rhapsody since December 31, 1996 (852 shows) featured the Late Show Gospel Choir singing on risers behind the band and Ghost quotes from Page and the choir with subsequent lyrics changed to reference Ghost. The first Jungle Boogie since December 31, 2003 (544 shows) featured the BD Entertainment Marching Band marching band along with the choir. The marching band and choir were also featured in Wilson where a platform above Trey that had appeared for the entire New Year's run descended and the clone that had been lying on the platform rose and was revealed to be a Tom Hanks actor from Cast Away. Inflated Wilson volleyballs were then tossed into the crowd. Only the final verse was sung in Wilson which contained Jungle Boogie quotes and was unfinished. During Auld Lang Syne, Phish briefly stopped playing and ate cake in front of the stage while the marching band and choir continued to perform. Carini featured several dancers in "naked dude" costumes emerging from a birthday cake in front of the stage and dancing and running around with security trying to catch them. The Theme from New York, New York was performed for the first time since December 31, 1997 (774 shows) and featured the naked dude dancers performing a kickline in front of the stage while adding vocals and Trey changing the lyrics to "if I could be naked there." Page teased Tweezer in Caspian. Piper contained Crosseyed quotes. During Tweezer Reprise, the wombat ran and danced across the stage. The post show music was Goodbye Yellow Brick Road, which was a nod to Phish playing their 72nd show at Madison Square Garden, tying Elton John.

Fluffhead was unfinished. Trey teased Dave's Energy Guide in Bathtub Gin. This show featured the Phish debut of Hey Stranger. Trey teased Heartbreaker in Ruby Waves.

Trey teased A Wave of Hope in Twist. Mike teased Plasma in Harry Hood.

Trey teased Mr. P.C. in David Bowie. Icculus was dedicated to PI (Phish's stage manager Paul Ingwersen who was retiring that night). PI was subsequently mentioned in Icculus. Trey referenced Icculus in Character Zero with "read the book!" quotes. The soundcheck's Jam was followed by In the Summertime and Right Place, Wrong Time quotes.

Trey teased There is a Mountain in Walls of the Cave and Sigma Oasis. Kill Devil Falls, Sigma Oasis, and Moma Dance were unfinished. Thunderhead was performed for the first time since December 1, 2003 (544 shows). Trey teased Thunderhead in Moma Dance. Fee featured Trey on megaphone.

This show started late and consisted of only one set due to a lengthy delay following a thunderstorm. Carini's lyrics were changed to "at least he had some boots" in reference to streaker who ran out onto the field during the weather delay wearing only a pair of boots. Trey teased Nothing's Gonna Stop Us Now in Carini and Streets of Cairo during Tweezer.

Sand and Down with Disease were unfinished.

Gotta Jibboo was unfinished. Reba did not contain the whistling ending. Trey whistled in the intro to the first Martian Monster and eventually joined Fish on drums. The Phish debut of Broken Heart Attack featured Fish on vacuum. The second Martian Monster featured Trey on drums, Fish on Marimba Lumina, and a David Bowie intro tease from Trey while on drums. The Possum intro featured Fish playing the drums with one hand with his other drumstick in the air and Trey quoting Broken Heart Attack.

Trey teased 1999 in Fluffhead and Taste and Crazy Train in Mr. Completely.

Twist contained Clear Your Mind quotes. Ghost included a Fire (Ohio Players) tease from Trey and Ass Handed quotes. Page teased the theme from Speed Racer in The Lizards.

Down with Disease was unfinished.

Mike and Trey teased Sweet Emotion in Carini. Trey teased Mr. P.C. in YEM.

Trey teased Norwegian Wood in 555. Heavy Rotation was performed for the first time since July 22, 2015 (253 shows). Trey teased Under Pressure in Simple. During the soundcheck, Beth was briefly sung by Trey and Knuckle Bone Broth Avenue contained Shipwreck quotes as well as If I Only Had A Brain teases from Trey and Mike.

Soul Planet contained a tease of Dave's Energy Guide from Trey and a tease of Dog Log from Mike. Trey teased Midnight Rider in the first Down with Disease and No Quarter in Ghost. Shipwreck was quoted in Sleeping Monkey. Mike teased Dave's Energy Guide in Free.

Kill Devil Falls was unfinished. My Friend's ending did not contain the "Myfe" lyric. Trey teased Freeway Jam in Kill Devil Falls. Carini contained a full-band tease of Low Rider. Trey teased Thread in No Men In No Man's Land and San-Ho-Zay in Twist. Trey dedicated Bug to Jovi who was in attendance and had previously joined him on stage to sing the song earlier in the year during his solo acoustic performance in Grand Rapids. Due to the combination of an extended delay to the start of the show from lightning and a curfew for the venue, setbreak was canceled.

Mike teased Twenty Years Later in Ghost. Mike and Trey teased Those Were the Days before Halley's Comet.

Shafty was performed over the jam out of Halfway to the Moon. Mike teased Miss You (Rolling Stones) in Strawberry Letter 23 and Flash Light in Character Zero.

Stash was unfinished. Carini contained Martian Monster quotes. Piper included Odd Couple theme teases from Trey and BBFCFM quotes. Trey teased Call to the Post in Wilson.

DWD was unfinished.

Trey teased Mr. P.C. in Tube.

Set Your Soul Free contained a short Crosseyed and Painless jam with quotes from Trey. Twist included an Oye Como Va tease from Trey and Crosseyed quotes from Trey and Mike. Trey played The Star-Spangled Banner in its entirety during Fire.

Gumbo was unfinished and contained a Long Tall Glasses tease from Page.

Runaway Jim contained a Nellie Kane tease by Trey. Kill Devil Falls was unfinished. David Bowie featured an In Memory of Elizabeth Reed tease by Trey.

Space Oddity was played for the first time since July 28, 2017 (154 shows). The third Tweezer contained teases of Izabella and Cissy Strut. Trey teased Dave's Energy Guide in Piper. Also Sprach Zarathustra included Space Oddity quotes and teases from Trey and Martian Monster quotes from Trey and Page. Trey quoted I'm Waiting for the Man in Character Zero. The soundcheck's Seven Below Jam was initially performed at a faster pace than normal before switching to a bluegrass style.

Trey teased Norwegian Wood in First Tube.

Chalk Dust Torture was unfinished. Trey teased Dave's Energy Guide in Plasma and Tweezer Reprise in Weekapaug.

The first Sand contained Crosseyed and Painless teases from Mike and an Albert tease from Trey. Mike teased Dueling Banjos in Slave to the Traffic Light.

Stealing Time From the Faulty Plan had an Odd Couple theme tease from Trey. This show included the first performance of the slow arrangement of Maze.

Trey teased Happy Birthday in Boogie On Reggae Woman and Contact.

Mike teased Do You Feel Like We Do before Dirt. Trey teased Prince Caspian near the end of Egg in a Hole. Piper contained Guy Forget teases and quotes from Page and Manteca teases from Trey. Nothing was last played on January 15, 2017 (158 shows). The Oh Kee Pa Ceremony was last played October 20, 2018 (108 shows). The soundcheck's My Soul had Guy Forget lyrics from Fish.

My Friend My Friend did not contain the "Myfe" ending. Mike sung part of Passing Through in Light. Golgi's lyrics were changed to "I saw you with a barcode in your hand." Trey and Fish teased Mr. Completely in 46 Days.

Trey teased San-Ho-Zay in Weekapaug Groove.

My Mind's Got a Mind of its Own was performed for the first time since October 25, 2013 (285 shows). Page teased Frankenstein in The Final Hurrah. Fish teased Mr. Completely in Walk Away.

Llama was performed in an alternate arrangement. Quadrophonic Toppling was performed for the first time since December 31, 1999 (606 shows). Mike teased Dueling Banjos in Chalk Dust Torture. During the soundcheck, Mike quoted Got My Mojo Working in the jam and Trey quoted My Shot after The Final Hurrah as well as Another Brick in the Wall Part 2 in Gumbo.

This was the the rescheduled date for the show that had been postponed due to the Omicron variant of COVID-19 surge in New York City in December of 2021. Mike teased Party Time in the first Simple. Trey teased San-Ho-Zay in No Men in No Man's Land, Dave's Energy Guide in Piper, and In Memory of Elizabeth Reed in David Bowie.

This was the rescheduled date for the show that had been postponed due to the Omicron variant of COVID-19 surge in New York City in December of 2021. Mike quoted Quadrophonic Toppling in Axilla (Part II). Trey teased Happy Birthday in Set Your Soul Free and wished his daughter Bella a happy birthday in Backwards Down the Number Line. For the third set and encore, the stage was raised with a screen showing moving images in front of and below the band. During Waves, dolphins and a whale flew throughout the venue. Kelp descended from above the band during Split Open and Melt and fell to the stage after the song was over. Prior to It's Ice, there was a prerecorded freezing sound as the image on the screen "froze."

This was the rescheduled date for the show that had been postponed due to the Omicron variant of COVID-19 surge in New York City in December of 2021. Suzy Greenberg was dedicated to “the hero of the song,” Suzy Greenberg, who was attending her first Phish show. Trey teased Jean Pierre in 46 Days. Chalk Dust Torture was unfinished. 2001 contained Super Bad and Martian Monster teases. Mike quoted Kung and teased Plasma in Harry Hood. Trey teased Heartbreaker in the first Character Zero and Tweezer in the second Character Zero.

This was the rescheduled date for the show that had been postponed due to the Omicron variant of COVID-19 surge in New York City in December of 2021. Moma Dance was unfinished. Page teased Long Tall Glasses in Gumbo.

Fat Man in the Bathtub was performed for the first time since December 30, 2010 (387 shows). After Weekapaug, Trey quoted a line from Silence of the Lambs and Page added a Shipwreck quote. My Friend My Friend did not contain the "Myfe" ending. Trey teased On Broadway in Split Open and Melt. Trey teased San-Ho-Zay and Third Stone From the Sun in No Men In No Man's Land.

This show contained the Phish debut of (I Can’t Get No) Satisfaction, albeit a partial version containing only the first verse and chorus. The unfinished Down with Disease's lyrics were changed to reference "sand" and "beach." Trey teased Wading in the Velvet Sea in Antelope.

This show featured two bustouts: Peaches en Regalia, which was performed for the first time since July 22, 2017 (139 shows), and The Maker, which was performed for the first time since October 15, 1994 (1,001 shows). So Damn Lucky also made its Phish debut at this show. Tweezer contained Freddie's Dead teases from Trey and The Lizards teases from Trey and Page. Trey teased Tweezer in Soul Planet and Tube. Trey teased Smoke on the Water in Meat. The encore featured Dave Matthews on guitar and vocals.